Auntie Janey’s Old-Fashioned Agony Column # 24: What a good girl really wants is a bad, bad boy
Dear Auntie Janey,
There seems to be a scarcity in the number of straight males who ask you for advice so let me reverse this trend.
I am 27, currently between jobs, waiting for my certificate of registration in a career that involves the ill, the dying, and the walking dead. As far as I can remember I have never ever been close to getting into a relationship. My high school and early college years are accounted for, I was into Star Trek (particularly Deep Space Nine), Douglas Adams, and Dungeons & Dragons (having been the DM of a cabal in Diliman). I know how girl-repellent these can be. And, no, no matter how hard cosplaying girls pretend to be geeks, there is just something odd about their brand of fanaticism. It is like staring at the Uncanny Valley, there is just something off. As for those female true believers, all of the ones I have met are taken.
Of course, the other thing that probably marked me as someone to be avoided when it comes to intimacy was my foolish habit of writing “poems” to girls I am attracted to. Those were painfully misguided years. I have done enough penance.
The closest I can say I ever got to having a girlfriend was during the closing days of my undergraduate years. At the time I met someone in an elective class who had the same taste in books and, generally, the same interests. In the few months or so that we knew each other, we had a friendship that can only be described as tempestuous. We would be revealing secrets one day, then the next day completely ignoring and not talking to each other and then back to talking. It was a cycle. This went on for months after graduation when our paths diverged as I continued studying while she started working. Then we had a huge fight. I will be honest enough and confess that I started it because I was exhausted with my efforts at trying to chase her when it was clear in her head that she could never see me as more than a friend.
We have reconciled since then, but as with such reconciliations, things could never go back to the way they once were. During the process of catching up, I discovered that the whole time she and I were talking about leo@fergusrules.com, acceptable breaks in reality, and friendship in the age of Friendster (this was half a decade ago) she had been seeing men who can only be described as bastards, assholes, and deadbeats, whose career plans were either non-existent or were limited to whatever handouts their parents gave them. The worst part of my rejection: finding out that she had chosen someone who had a history of violence against his girlfriend over me.
My story does not end there. I am currently infatuated with a former colleague, which I find a bit tiresome because years earlier when I had obliquely admitted I had feelings for her, she struck me down by telling me straight out via text message that she was not interested. In spite of this, I never really lost my attraction.
It is traditional that in this kind of letter one has to point out how normal or even superior the letter-writer is to the general population in order to make the lack of significant other a total mystery. So I will just state plainly that I bathe twice a day, brush my teeth regularly, have no facial deformities, and, in spite of being temporarily jobless, I consider myself a responsible person and I do my job well.
I point this out because in my line of work I’ve met women who have incurred physical injuries from assaults by other women after some Casanova in their barangay became reckless in his two-timing; women who have had children (averaging at about 4) with men who were already married; and women who swallowed 20 tablets of acetaminophen or ingested warfarin over men who did not love them back.
So this is where I not only ask the question why I do not have a girlfriend, I also ask why are there so many deadbeats, men without any ambition or future to speak, of who have women jumping all over them.
The usual answer to the first question does not apply. I am and always will have eyes only for women. And, no, this question does not bother me enough to cause me distress, at least not anymore. I would just like to have your input regarding these mysteries.
Sincerely,
27 and (Still) Single Since Birth
Jane Campion’s The Piano: Good girl Holly Hunter falls for (literally) dirty bad boy Harvey Keitel, gets fingers chopped off by stern boring husband Sam Neill.
Dear 27 and (Still) Single Since Birth,
Having read your letter I get the impression that you are a witty, funny, intelligent, decent and, as you have explicitly pointed out, straight man. Unfortunately my friend, these are not enough to snag you a girl or even a boy (boys are actually more picky than girls when choosing boys).
I once had a roommate who had a thing for foreign girls. After months of distant longing for an American girl, he put on his striped long-sleeved polo, puffed up his chest, gathered what confidence he had and approached the girl of his dreams in broad daylight and in front of the whole school. He introduced himself, declared his undying love, and offered her a brand new copy of The Silmarillion. To say that the girl was taken aback is an understatement but at least she had the decency to not accept his gift and to politely decline his affections.
We were not yet roommates when it happened but he told me about it during a moment of frustration about his non-existent lovelife. “I’m a decent guy” he told me with a pained expression and his suffering was evident in his eyes. “Why do good, decent girls go for guys who do not amount to anything? I have a degree (it was more of a certificate for a two-year course) and these guys that they go after will never even finish college!”
I did not have my Auntie Janey powers back then and I was more interested in the fact that he offered the girl a copy of the book I had been longing to read than concerned for his emotional well-being.
Now that I have seen some of the lands that lay beyond the fairy mists that bordered my homeland, I can tell you this: Good, decent girls go for uncouth deadbeat men because these girls are tired of being good and decent and they want excitement and unpredictability in their lives. Yes, this is true even though a lot of educated high-achieving girls would go “Eeeeeeeeewwwwwww” at the thought.
It is a fact, and I can show you examples in my workplace, of girls who have college degrees, who graduated with honors, or even have post-graduate degrees, falling for janitors, drivers, security guards, and utility men. Some of them have been impregnated or are in the process of planning their weddings. I know of one girl who went to one of the top universities and ended up with a fisherman.
A lot of our ladies, especially the purportedly good and decent ones, are oppressed by the role and image they have to portray. All of us also know that being good and predictable all the time is boring. Well-behaved women also want excitement and danger yet they have no opportunity to experience this since they are imprisoned within the routines dictated by society, their parents and their peers. Then an uncouth man comes along embodying danger, adventure and the forbidden. Humans have always been fascinated by the forbidden. Eve was so bored with Adam and the predictability of Paradise that she was seduced by the sinuous and large snake who offered her a taste of something she never had.
We all have our primal urges and desires. We have been taught to suppress them as giving in to them would be disruptive to our lives and society. Our system of education focuses on the dominance of the intellect over the senses. By the time we have gotten our degrees most of us no longer have any idea of how it is to be primal and sensual. What these “uneducated” men have over the degree holders is that they are more in touch with their primal selves. And they know how to arouse it in others. Girls, who never had the opportunity to explore their sensuality, are taken aback when strange feelings and desires are awakened. And so they fall into a world where pain and pleasure are the same. Logic and reason are just flimsy and artificial creations of man and they can easily be swept away by primal forces.
Bathing twice a day, brushing your teeth regularly, having no facial deformities, and being a responsible person will gain you friends, but not lovers. You have to be a little wild, playful, naughty, aggressive, and raw at times. Learn to loosen the seals that are suppressing the forces within. After all, what a good girl really wants is a bad, bad boy.
Namarié,
Auntie Janey
The opinions expressed in Auntie Janey’s Old-Fashioned Agony Column are those of the agony columnist alone and do not reflect the opinions of the owner and administrator of JessicaRulestheUniverse.com. As with all advice, follow at your own peril.
Would you like Auntie Janey to meddle in your life? Email agoniesforauntiejaney@gmail.com.
August 19th, 2011 at 15:43
27 and (Still) Single Since Birth, Auntie Janey said it right. I don’t know where I heard this line: the reason cliches are overused is because they are powerful and true. And the “bad boy gets the girl” cliche is no exception. Forget about 500 Days of Summer. Think of Denzel’s Training Day or Brad Pitt’s Fight Club.
August 19th, 2011 at 19:43
Star Trek? DnD? Where have you been all my life? *bats eyelashes*
Of course, the girl-repellent issue still stands, as I am also a guy. I am, however, not very picky when choosing guys. Ah well. Back to hoarding Terry Pratchett.
August 19th, 2011 at 22:29
I like punks.
August 19th, 2011 at 23:01
Momelia: You must be a good girl.
August 20th, 2011 at 02:07
Or something! Ahaha!
August 20th, 2011 at 02:45
27 and (Still) Single Since Birth: Do not equate being intelligent, educated, good and responsible with being boring. You’re only boring when you’re overly focused on yourself and lack consideration for the interests of others. No one likes a bore.
As for becoming more in touch with your primal self, a little self-knowledge is always a good thing. However, “what a good girl really wants is a bad, bad boy” is just a cliche. Cliches are cliches because they’re SIMPLE and overused, not because they’re necessarily true.
I offer proof that there are good girls out there who long for a good guy. I have been a Star Trek fan since TOS, signed up for the Merry Marvel Marching Society, played DnD back when it was still published by TSR, and I have Kindle subscriptions to Analog and Asimov’s. I have graduate degrees in science and business, and I’ve always tried to be responsible. By the way, she doesn’t share them, but she does indulge me my geeky interests.
We have two daughters, lovely and smart and fierce like their mother. I met her when I was 28.
August 20th, 2011 at 05:41
I don’t date but I do get attracted to guys who look like they’re up to no good. Why? Because I feel like I can “fix them” (feeling messianic). Then I realized these guys are not broken things that need to be repaired and that was that.
August 20th, 2011 at 08:34
My god! This guy is a male version of me. We should swap war stories, 27 and (Still) Single Since Birth.
And I beg to differ. Not ALL good girls like bad boys. I’m a pretty decent person and I don’t go for rebels because they seem like a colossal waste of energy.
Plus I hate the thought of having a ‘palamunin’ in my life when I’ve worked so hard to get to where I am. It doesn’t seem fair.
August 20th, 2011 at 08:55
No wonder the characters portrayed by James Dean, Sean Penn, Mickey Rourke, and Robin Padilla in films have always drawn both female and male viewers.
I wonder what the majestic Jessica prefers.
August 20th, 2011 at 09:29
Treat a princess like a tramp, and a tramp like a princess. You should be fine.
August 20th, 2011 at 20:03
Confession: Even at my sluttiest phase, I have always harbored a secret yearning for the bookish, buttoned-up type. Why, I don’t know. Partly because I was 1) surrounded by nerds all my life, 2) find the scowl-and-leather jacket combo overrated (sorry, Binoe and James Dean), and 3) crushed harder on Christopher Reeve and Harrison Ford for rocking the glasses and tailored suits better than their actual hero getups*… but mostly because I always knew that I would never get the kind of smart, snappy conversations about books and movies with the Bad Boy Archetype. Sure, I did date actual Bad Boys, but I always ended up vastly disappointed by their persistence to get into my pants before everything else. Sorry, Bad Boys of the world, but “a little less conversation and a little more action” means nothing without the capacity for original thought.
Point being: Boring guys, “good” or “bad,” are still BORING. If you want to be interesting, be interested first.
—–
*Unfortunately, the top two spots on my current Celebrity Pretend Boyfriend List are currently occupied by the least nerdy actors to be cast as major nerd heroes (*ahem*Hawkeye*ahem*MalcolmReynolds*ahem*), so what do I know? Does that mean I just want someone I can insult easily?
August 24th, 2011 at 13:40
OK, I may be generalizing here, but one thing I’ve observed from guys who say “I’m a nice guy, why don’t girls like me?” is that they try a bit too hard — and are shocked when they are not preferred. Girls (and this goes for guys too) don’t want someone who seems so eager to please but then secretly feels like we owe them our attention. Passive aggressiveness is not attractive at all, nice guy or not.