The thing is, it doesn’t feel like stealing. To call it stealing would be too sordid. You’re convinced that you’re restoring sense to an irrational universe. Why is that book on that shelf when, if justice and fairness truly exist, it would rightfully be yours? Why leave it there to be pawed over by cretins who don’t deserve to read it, much less turn its pages? To have those hallowed words register on the optic nerves of some creature who can’t read without moving his lips! It’s an abomination! Might as well smear your hands with peanut butter and jelly and touch Leonardo’s notebooks.
Or maybe you just want it. You have to have it, but you don’t have the money, and by the time you get the money it might be gone forever. Or maybe you’ve lived an exemplary life and you just want to do something bad, but nothing so tacky as to shoplift a shirt or a comb. A book distinguishes you from (other) petty thieves: you’re not filching a mere object, but a life with paper for flesh and ink for blood.
OF COURSE IT’S A CRIME. But at the exact moment when you casually take the book, slip it into your bag, and walk out the door, it feels like a mission. You are all that stands between the forces of enlightenment and the hordes of ignorance. You are a knight of the printed word.
You are a thief rationalizing your offence.
Here is your chance at expiation. Confess and be shriven. (If your pseudonym does not provide enough concealment, attribute the crime to “My friend”. My own friends I conceal under the names of royal houses, historical and science-fictional.)
Arisugawa-no-miya snitched The Complete Works of V.I. Lenin from Erehwon Bookstore in Katipunan in 1972. He assures me that Erehwon and Katipunan Avenue both existed in 1972.
The House of Zogu (royal family of Albania, possibly related to Florante at Laura), stole The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich from a bookstore. “It was a stupid, stupid thing to do since it was a hardcover book and more than a thousand pages thick, with a giant swastika on the cover. I just walked out with it on Avenida, Rizal, and forever abjured a life of crime. Never read the damn thing.”
Hohenzollern-Singmaringen swiped The Rape of Tamar from the Harvard library. The girl he was seeing at the time made him give it back. He never spoke to her again.
Thyssen-Bornemisza stole a Spanish-English Gideon Bible from a hotel room in Madrid. “I needed to work on my Spanish,” he explains. “That’s not stealing,” I point out. “The Gideons wanted you to have it.” “But you’re supposed to put it back in the drawer.” He insists it was stealing.
Hohenstaufen and Swabia took T.H. White’s The Sword in the Stone from the Assumption grade school library. “I felt that it was mine to begin with—because it WAS mine to begin with.” She had left her book in school, and someone put it in the library. It still had her name on it, so she simply stole it back. Later she pilfered Economic Cooperation in ASEAN from another library, and is still wracked with guilt—not at the theft, but at the choice of reading matter.
Fushimi-no-miya made off with a Stanford University library copy of Little Brown Brother by Leon Wolff.
Borbon y Battenberg pilfered Of Love and Other Demons by Gabriel Garcia Marquez from a bookstore “dahil sa pagmamahal ko kay Marquez. Gusto ko lang siyang kunin dahil wala akong pambili. Gaya ni Marquez, nagnanakaw ako dahil ganid ako sa kaalaman.”
House Corrino took The Philippine-American War, compiled by Fred Cordova, from the library of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, but insists it was not stealing because they were going to throw out the books anyway.
Harkonnen-Atreides pinched The Collected Stories of John Cheever from a bookstore.
Fenring and Rabban hatched an elaborate plan to get free books. They managed to convince a foundation that their thesis room in the UP Department of Chemistry had a real library. For years they regularly received donations of chemistry and science-fiction books. I was a happy beneficiary of this scheme.
Confess.
P.S. “Too bad the Index doesn’t include perps who were actually caught. Are they now famous politicians or CEOs who have moved on to greater public larcenies (after trying to steal Archie Comics), or are they now lost souls, potential laureates who failed at stealing the one book that could have changed their lives? The evidence may still be found in fading mugshots scotchtaped to the broken glass doors of bookstores that closed years ago.” – The House of Zogu