It’s 1985! Put on your smiley face.
1. Watchmen works! It’s loyal to the comics but won’t alienate non-readers. More importantly it’s not an expensively-animated storyboard, it’s a crazy spectacle. We are disturbed and unsettled, and We Like It.
2. The actors’ resemblance to their graphic equivalents is uncanny: they seem to have walked out of the pages. (Except Matthew Goode, see below.)
3. After the opening scenes we’re guessing director Zack Snyder was strapped down and restrained from having all the action rendered in slow-motion. Excellent decision, or the movie would’ve run four hours instead of two hours, forty minutes.
4. Malin Akerman as Silk Spectre II looks good but her delivery is robotic. Not her fault though that her fight scenes are like shampoo commercials. Billy Crudup as the anatomically-correct Dr. Manhattan has the worst gig on earth playing a character who has lost touch with his humanity. And yet he is operatically emotional compared to Matthew Goode, who plays Veidt as a marionette. Jeffrey Dean Morgan makes an oddly touching (for a total scumbag) Comedian and Carla Gugino’s Sally is a great old broad. Patrick Wilson is exactly how we imagined Dan Dreiberg. Jackie Earle Haley turns Rorschach into a figure out of Greek tragedy, and we hardly even see his face. He is the festering soul of this tale.
5. The movie is loud enough, but it gets deafening when there’s music on the soundtrack. We know the rights to the Dylan, Hendrix, Cohen etc recordings are expensive, but you don’t have to blow out our eardrums to get your money’s worth.
6. Ah, there’s the reason we don’t get to see the iMax version in the Philippines: the sex scene has noticeable cuts. We don’t really mind as the scene is cheesy, hilarious, and goes on too long. Hmm, there’s constant carnage in this movie—cleavers to the head, limbs spurting blood, bones breaking, bodies exploding, boiling fat on human flesh. Apparently violence is acceptable, but sex is verboten.
7. Trying to make a spoiler not a spoiler: the mass devastation is less squishy than we’d anticipated.
8. The movie is true to its uncredited creator’s vision. It turns the superhero genre inside out (often literally). There is no triumphalism, no saving the day, just bitterness, regret, self-loathing, corrosion and dark irony. It’s a downer, and it’s just what we wanted.
The Simpsons: Always anti-reverence.
An hour before the movie we heard the news that Francis Magalona had died. (Weird how the Eraserheads reunion concerts are preceded by wakes. First Ely’s mother, and now the band’s great friend and colleague.) We knew he was very ill, but we assumed he would recover. We grieve for Francis and his family, for all of us and for the music we’ve lost.