Everything we’ve always wanted to say about poverty porn. . .now in movie form!
Thank you Marlon Rivera (director), Chris Martinez (writer), Eugene Domingo (star) and everyone involved in the making of Ang Babae Sa Septic Tank, the box-office hit and awards juggernaut at the recent Cinemalaya festival. You have saved me the trouble of letting off a rant that might’ve spoiled my mood and that of the sensitive people who would feel alluded to.
Everything we’ve always wanted to say about poverty porn—movies, mostly independently-produced, which focus on the squalor and desperation of the underclass in Philippine society—is encapsulated in Ang Babae Sa Septic Tank, the story of young filmmakers making an “authentic” “social realist” film that they hope will win Oscars (Note multiple ironies in that sentence). Except that the movie says it visually, hilariously, and better.
To recap:
1. Independent cinema—Indies—used to be an economic model, i.e. movies produced outside of the studio system. With the success of local indies, “success” being defined as entry into the international film festival circuit (there being few local indies that have had lucrative theatrical runs), Indie has become a style.
Therefore the attributes that used to be associated with low-budget indie guerilla filmmaking—shaky, grainy, poorly-lit, underexposed photography, terrible sound, poor-quality technicals—are now required of the movies. These have become their “signature”.
It appears that the godfather of local indie cinema is The Blair Witch Project.
Indies denounce mainstream movies for sticking with tired old formulas—now they have their own formula.
2. The fact of the matter is that foreign film festivals are partial to Filipino movies with this “style” and subject matter. (They’re like the visiting photographers who demand to be taken straight to Smokey Mountain or Payatas. We cannot deny the reality of poverty, but that’s not all we are.)
In effect indie filmmakers are making movies for foreign festival programmers and critics. They ignore the general Pinoy audience which “doesn’t understand” their work, and the general Pinoy audience ignores them right back because they’re “depressing”.
3. The makers of poverty movies are tourists, and not because they travel the international festival circuit. Tourists as in “sightseers”, the slums being the sights.
4. Whatever the intention, however faithful to “grim reality”, poverty movies are still a form of exploitation (hence, porn).
5. Poverty movies are every bit as artificial as slick studio movies. They’re movies, aren’t they?
When actress Eugene Domingo playing the star Eugene Domingo who may or may not be based on the real Eugene Domingo discusses the three types of acting—”Elevator”, “TV Patrol” and “As is, where is”, the chips I was eating shot out of my nose.
Bravo everyone, particularly Marlon Rivera. Not content with being the overlord of a multinational ad agency, a teacher at the UP College of Fine Arts, a fashion designer, florist, and so many other things that we grow exhausted from enumerating them, Marlon has gone and made this clever movie. Do not miss it.
Ang Babae Sa Septic Tank is now showing in Power Plant, Glorietta, Trinoma, Market Market, Gateway, Robinsons and all SM theatres.
August 3rd, 2011 at 21:52
I sat in Sir Marlon’s advertising class in FA years ago, and it was so interesting that I wished I was taking up Viscomm. I tried to watch the movie in UP last week but it was sold out, and there was a very long line of people waiting for standing room tickets even when they’ve already sold out hours ago (it’s like lining up for enlistment, hahaha). I’m happy they’re running it in regular theatres, I can buy tickets!
August 4th, 2011 at 03:41
Ooh, I remember. This is the movie where Eugene Domingo literally fell in the poso negro while filming.
August 4th, 2011 at 11:21
Laughtrip to kagabe sa LFS ng Gay-way, Cubao! “As is, where is” acting is the bomb!
August 4th, 2011 at 14:09
indie filmmakers should make movies that cater to niche audiences or middle class filipino viewers (who still have spending money), since the poor can’t afford to watch these movies in theaters anymore for P150 a ticket.
August 5th, 2011 at 09:44
It’s also showing in Waltermart makati.
August 5th, 2011 at 10:11
Does anybody know how Pinoys overseas can watch this movie?
August 5th, 2011 at 10:26
Watched it last night at Powerplant, LFS. The moviehouse was about 3/4 full and highly appreciative. I went out of the moviehouse with the feeling that my money was well-spent :)
August 5th, 2011 at 13:05
I say this in all seriousness: this movie is right up there with Fellini’s 8 1/2, Robert Altman’s The Player, Truffaut’s La Nuit Americaine, Vincente Minnelli’s The Bad and the Beautiful.
August 6th, 2011 at 01:02
Just got home from the cinema. I was madly cackling throughout the movie. “How is Ms. Eugene today?”