The Buried Giant is now available at National Bookstores, Php799. Ishiguro’s previous genre-ish novel Never Let Me Go, Php315.
Ooh, major writers fighting. Well, Ursula Le Guin attacking and Kazuo Ishiguro defending.
It started with this interview in the New York Times, in which the author of The Remains of the Day and Never Let Me Go said
“I don’t know what’s going to happen,” he said. “Will readers follow me into this? Will they understand what I’m trying to do, or will they be prejudiced against the surface elements? Are they going to say this is fantasy?”
The author of The Left Hand of Darkness and The Dispossessed, whom we think should win a Nobel Prize because she’s brilliant and because recognition for science-fiction is way overdue, was not amused.
Well, yes, they probably will. Why not?
It appears that the author takes the word for an insult.
To me that is so insulting, it reflects such thoughtless prejudice, that I had to write this piece in response.
Fantasy is probably the oldest literary device for talking about reality.
‘Surface elements,’ by which I take it he means ogres, dragons, Arthurian knights, mysterious boatmen, etc., which occur in certain works of great literary merit such as Beowulf, the Morte d’Arthur, and The Lord of the Rings, are also much imitated in contemporary commercial hackwork. Their presence or absence is not what constitutes a fantasy. Literary fantasy is the result of a vivid, powerful, coherent imagination drawing plausible impossibilities together into a vivid, powerful and coherent story, such as those mentioned, or The Odyssey, or Alice in Wonderland.
To which Ishiguro replied:
“I think she wants me to be the new Margaret Atwood,” he said, referring to the criticism the Canadian author and poet has received from Le Guin for distinguishing her writing as “speculative fiction” and for saying science fiction was about “talking squids in outer space”.
“If there is some sort of battle line being drawn for and against ogres and pixies appearing in books, I am on the side of ogres and pixies,” he said. “I had no idea this was going to be such an issue. Everything I read about [The Buried Giant], it’s all ‘Oh, he’s got a dragon in his book’ or ‘I so liked his previous books but I don’t know if I’ll like this one’.
“[Le Guin]’s entitled to like my book or not like my book, but as far as I am concerned, she’s got the wrong person. I am on the side of the pixies and the dragons.”
What do you think? Weigh in on the “argument” and our favorite comment wins a copy of The Buried Giant.
* * * * *
Thanks, commenters, for the good points. We’ll give the book to the nerdiest personal perspective. balqis, it’s yours.